Ethical Considerations in the Pursuit of Academic Prestige: A Global South Perspective on Quality Assurance, Accreditation, and University Rankings
Published
Synopsis
The global pursuit of academic prestige is a defining feature of contemporary higher education, shaped by quality assurance mechanisms, accreditation regimes, and international university rankings. While often presented as neutral indicators of excellence, these instruments carry significant ethical implications, particularly in the Global South, where historical inequities, resource constraints, and contextual diversity shape institutional experiences. This chapter critically examines how prevailing models of quality assurance, accreditation, and rankings often reproduce structural asymmetries between the Global North and the Global South. Metrics privileging research outputs, English-language publications, and reputational indicators frequently marginalize local knowledge, teaching excellence, and societal engagement, generating ethical dilemmas such as compliance-driven practices, mission drift, and pressures on academic integrity. The chapter highlights how accreditation dependency, commercialization, and governance challenges exacerbate these ethical vulnerabilities, emphasizing the tensions between global visibility and local responsibility. In response, it proposes a context-sensitive ethical framework for pursuing academic prestige that aligns institutional aspirations with social responsibility, equity, and developmental relevance. By foregrounding Global South experiences, the chapter contributes to a more inclusive and ethically grounded understanding of academic prestige, offering actionable insights for policymakers, higher education leaders, and scholars seeking to balance global engagement with local impact.